Cordwainer Smith was a Golden Age sci fi writer with a fascinating biography. Smith’s works are not warm and fuzzy, by any means. They sort of remind me of the modernist inspired futuristic landscapes and interiors of spaceships from fifties; I imagine metallic things, instrument panels, pure, sterile white interiors. The first story, “Scanners Live in Vain,” Smith’s first and perhaps one of his most famous, concerns a guild of scanners, men (I say men because they really are all men. These are uh, stories with the attitude towards women typical of the era, although women can also become rulers in the Instrumentality, and there are many important female characters and protagonists) who have voluntarily become “habermen,” who are threatened by a scientific discovery which may put an end to their monopoly. Smith’s short stories tend to start in media res worldbuilding-wise, in which we come across a scene in which we have no idea what the background of the setting is, the specialized vocabulary, or the political/social context. The reader must construct this later.
The author’s prose tends to be fairly transparent, his made-up words seemingly familiar, yet enigmatic. The stories mainly take place within one universe, over a vast scale in time, with characters rarely repeating, and the story being about an incident of significance in galactic history. In this, they remind me slightly of Iain Banks’s Culture series (which you really should read); vast time scale, about a culture and ethos in total, rather than the saga of an individual (although both Banks and Smith are fairly good at creating interesting characters). Smith’s Instrumentality of Mankind rules in an ultra-technocratic, secretive way over a populace largely living in a boring happiness (until the Rediscovery of Mankind, in which disease and danger are introduced because without them people are less human). The sinister side of the Instrumentality is far more pronounced than the Culture’s, however (the attitude towards the Culture is far more positive, I think, within the books), and not only does the Instrumentality act totally without mercy towards their enemies, but treats the underpeople (animals given the shape and minds of humans, a la Island of Dr. Moreau) like trash (forming the theme of one Smith’s best known stories, the Dead Lady of Clown Town, in which a dog-girl named D’Joan is martyred trying to give her message of universal love.) The theme of spiritual ennui within a utopia without scarcity and extended life (made possible by stroon, a substance produced by the planet of Nostralia) also reminds me of some of Michael Moorcock’s novels about a utopia (dystopia?) at the end of time. This makes me want to try some of Smith’s longer works, to see how he develops these themes on a larger and less fragmentary scale.
tags>>cordwainer smith|dystopia
6 Responses for "Best of Cordwainer Smith"
w00t, you’ve finally read Smith. I can’t really say that Norstrilia is really what you’re looking for, however. It’s longer, yes, but to me it just seemed like an expanded short story.
[Reply]
charmian reply on March 19th, 2008 9:40 pm:
Yeah, Smith is definitely a weird author. I am not v. versed in early SF, so I don’t have much knowledge about how he differs from his contemporaries. But there’s just a power his stuff has which is difficult to analyze, even with the years SF has developed since him.
[Reply]
i discovered smith when i was very young, and he easily became one of my all-time favorite SF writers as a direct result
seriously, more people should read his stuff.
he had a good life, didn’t he? i especially love that part where his father (a US federal district judge based in the philippines) sent him off to live in russia when he was still young and starry-eyed about communism. he came back a lot more educated and a lot less starry-eyed. i don’t think that’s in the wiki entry you linked to, though…
while i liked norstrilia, i didn’t enjoy it as much as his short stories. “the crime and glory of commander suzdal” haunts me to this day, and “the ballad of lost c’mell” will always be one of the greatest SF love stories ever written, even if it’s arguably a bit weak by today’s standards.
[Reply]
charmian reply on March 19th, 2008 9:43 pm:
Yeah, I don’t know why he isn’t more well known. Well, his stuff isn’t “cuddly?” In that it’s sublime, but also weird and distancing at the same time, and things that should be loltastic (space captain sends cats into the future, and they come back to serve him and save him from hostile mpreg race!) instead are taken seriously, and it works! As do telepaths who are psychicly linked with cats to fight invisible space dragons/rats with nuclear bombs.
I kind of think it would be v. interesting for a fanartist to illustrate some of these stories as a comic. I’d love to see what they’d come up with as far as aesthetics goes.
[Reply]
morphaileffect reply on March 20th, 2008 6:15 am:
dude, i forgot about the mpreg. asdjhgfkjl i have to read that story again XD
the telepaths psychically linked with cats - or, rather, animals as highly sensitive, instinctive killers - is a srs concept that i believe he introduced, and has since been recycled in different media. we3 comes to mind especially, although i dunno if grant morrison actually had smith as an influence.
[Reply]
charmian reply on March 20th, 2008 6:29 am:
Indeed. XD It was quite interesting to see how that reflected on Smith’s views of gender, but it certainly proves that all male worlds and mpreg are not at all new ideas.
Oooh, interesting. Telepath friends! Also possibly quite inspiring to the furries, as the pinlighter wishes that the cat were human (finding her to be more intriguing than any human woman.) XD
[Reply]
Leave a reply